Cannot remember anymore for how many years Iβve been using Careline Graph-Ink Gel Liner. Aside from itβs very easy to use, it also has intense black pigment, long lasting, waterproof, smudge-proof and what I like the most is the thin brush tip for a fine, sharp cat eye. Natural, more dramatic, the better! To purchase, click the yellow basket below: @Careline #carelineph